From Doing It All to Holding the Steady Center: What New Managers Learn

From Doing It All to Holding the Steady Center: What New Managers Learn

Most people get promoted because they're excellent at doing the work. Then the role changes, and the habits that made them excellent start to get in the way.

The habit that stops working

Jordan is a composite of several leaders I've coached, with details changed.

As an individual contributor, Jordan made dozens of small decisions a day and owned every one. As a manager, the same instinct kept Jordan at the center of everything: the decider, the fixer, the one who absorbed what others dropped. Jordan had breadth across many things and not enough room to go deep on the few that mattered.

Jordan also judged themselves harshly. A missed call or a hard conversation put off became evidence of falling short. The harshness didn't make Jordan better. It made Jordan tired.

Starting with the person

We began with Jordan, not the team. Self-compassion came first: treating a setback with the kindness you'd offer a colleague, and remembering that every new manager struggles with this and you're not alone in it. Jordan noticed that over-identifying with weaknesses crowded out strengths. Seeing the whole picture again brought relief.

Next came the pause: six seconds before responding. It sounds small. For Jordan it was the gap between reacting to a tense moment and choosing a response. Jordan could listen fully to someone's frustration, take in what they felt, and not be pulled into it.

From asking to owning

The second shift was about direction. Jordan was used to looking outward for the answer: gathering consensus from the whole team, or waiting to hear what the manager wanted. Majority rule felt safe, but it also slowed everything down and left Jordan's own judgment out of the room.

As Jordan’s confidence grew, so did their willingness to make decisions and take action. They still listened, but listening was no longer the same as seeking consensus. Instead of asking, “What do you want?” Jordan began to present a clear stance: “Here’s what I see and what I recommend. What are your thoughts?”

That meant:

  • Deciding with input, not by vote. Hearing people out fully, then making the call and explaining the reasoning.

  • Owning a position with the manager. Doing the analysis first and walking in ready for a courageous conversation.

  • Naming problems clearly. A vague "there's friction" can be dismissed as people bickering. Specific issues and their impact get taken seriously.

  • Delegating. Giving real ownership to others and supporting their growth, not just handing off tasks.

  • Staying warm while becoming direct. Jordan's people skills were a strength, not something to give up.

Being the steady center

In uncertain times, a team looks to its manager for stability. Jordan worked on communicating purpose and framing as well as content: defining roles, following up, and saying early what was coming. Jordan also learned to say no, to protect people from overextension before it turned into burnout.

Jordan’s steadiness was rooted in intentional self-care: consistent sleep, regular rest, time outdoors, nourishing meals, movement, and brief breaks woven through the day. Prioritizing physical and mental wellbeing stopped being optional—it became part of his leadership strategy. When you protect your energy and resilience, you lead with clarity, presence, and sustained impact.

Questions to try

  • Where am I still making every decision when someone else could own it?

  • Where am I waiting for agreement or permission when I already have a view?

  • What would change if I spoke to myself as I would to a colleague?

  • What's the one issue I haven't named clearly to the person who can act on it?

  • What small pause could I add before my next hard conversation?

If you're stepping into a bigger role, I'd be glad to talk. Learn about the IInside-Out Leadership Development Program or book a conversation with Sharon.

Hit a Bump at Work? How Leaders Turn a Setback Into a Turning Point